Skip to content

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark 2026: Which VPN Is Better?

Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.

This Private Internet Access vs Surfshark comparison puts two low-priced, unlimited-device VPNs side by side. Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, has three Deloitte audits, two US federal court cases and open-source apps. Surfshark has two Deloitte no-logs audits, reviews of its apps and infrastructure by other firms, and a Dutch warrant it answered with payment details only. Neither limits how many devices you connect, so the choice rests on evidence, ownership and price over time.

Short version: pick PIA if you want port forwarding, open-source apps and a no-logs claim tested in US federal court. Pick Surfshark if you want audits you can check from public announcements, a 7-day trial and a bundle of extras such as ad blocking and Alternative ID. In the Private Internet Access vs Surfshark match-up we have not measured speed for either.

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark comparison card with both logos

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built

SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests for this page, so this Private Internet Access vs Surfshark page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our Private Internet Access review and our Surfshark review, plus pages we re-read: PIA’s plans page and transparency report on 16 November 2026, and Surfshark’s pricing page and transparency report in November. Surfshark’s pricing page showed local currency when we read it, so its dollar prices here come from September 2026 and its current Black Friday offer may be lower. Every source is linked at the end.

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark at a Glance

FeaturePIASurfshark
No-logs checks3 Deloitte audits: 2022, 2024, 2025Deloitte in 2023 and 2025; Cure53 and SecuRing reviews
Real-world recordUS federal court cases in 2016 and 2018 produced no user dataOne Dutch warrant in April 2026 answered with payment details only
Transparency reportQuarterly; Q3 2026 lists 9 requests, no logs producedQuarterly; July to September 2026 lists 23 inquiries and no warrants
Price, long plan$2.03/month for 3 years + 4 months ($81.20), 16 Nov. 2026$2.49/month on 2 years (Starter, Sept. 2026)
Month to month$11.95$16.45 (Sept. 2026)
DevicesUnlimitedUnlimited
ServersServers in 113 countries; RAM-only4,500+ servers in 100 countries; RAM-only
Money-back guarantee30 days, new subscribers only30 days, plus a 7-day trial in the app stores
Base and ownerUnited States; Kape Technologies since 2019Netherlands; Nord Security group since 2022

PIA’s prices are from 16 November 2026 and Surfshark’s dollar prices from September 2026. Both are promotional on long plans, and neither is converted from another currency. Check the renewal price before you pay.

No-Logs Evidence: Private Internet Access vs Surfshark

PIA says it has had three third-party audits, all by Deloitte, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. CyberInsider reports that the latest, finished in December 2025 under the ISAE 3000 standard, also covered PIA’s token-based dedicated IP system. We have not read the reports. PIA also says its servers run from RAM only.

Deloitte checked Surfshark’s no-logs policy in 2023 and again in 2025. The 2025 work produced an ISAE 3000 reasonable assurance report covering server configuration, deployment and privacy settings (Surfshark’s announcement). Cure53 audited its infrastructure in 2021 and 2026, and SecuRing tested the apps, browser extensions and infrastructure in 2025. Every Surfshark server runs from RAM only.

PIA has one large firm on a steady cycle, and Surfshark has the same firm plus several others looking at different parts. Both are real evidence, and neither proves a no-logs claim forever.

Court Cases, Warrants and Transparency Reports

PIA’s claim has been tested in US federal court. In 2016 a criminal complaint in an FBI bomb-threat case said a subpoena to PIA’s then owner returned nothing useful about the suspect, according to TorrentFreak. In 2018 PIA’s general counsel testified in a San Jose federal court that PIA keeps no logs that could answer a subpoena, in a hacking case decided on other evidence, as TorrentFreak reported. PIA’s own page dates its two subpoenas to 2016 and 2017, so the years differ by source. Both came before Kape bought PIA in 2019.

Surfshark’s test came from its own disclosure. In April 2026 a court in Amsterdam issued a warrant, and Surfshark confirmed that an account existed and handed over the payment details attached to it, with no record of what the person did online. That shows what a billing relationship means in practice: a paid VPN knows who pays.

PIA’s quarterly report for July to September 2026 lists two subpoenas, no warrants, four other government, law-enforcement or civil requests and three foreign or informal ones, with no logs produced. Surfshark’s latest report, for the same quarter, lists 23 inquiries from government institutions, no warrants and no national security letters, and says none led to disclosure of data about users’ online activity. Both reports are self-published.

Price and Plans

Both are cheap on long terms, and PIA is cheaper month to month at $11.95 against $16.45. Surfshark’s page spreads its long-plan price over 27 months, 24 plus three extra, and its current Black Friday offer may undercut the September figures here. PIA’s 3-year offer carries a promotion label and a crossed-out price, so read the order summary before you pay on either.

Surfshark’s pricing page also lists higher tiers that add antivirus, data-leak alerts and a data-removal service, and some identity-theft cover for US residents. PIA sells an antivirus add-on at checkout instead.

PlanPriceDevicesRefund
PIA, 3 years + 4 months$2.03/mo ($81.20); autorenews at $81.20 every 3 yearsUnlimited30 days, new subscribers
PIA, 1 year$3.99/mo ($47.88), then $47.88 a yearUnlimited30 days, new subscribers
PIA, monthly$11.95Unlimited30 days, new subscribers
Surfshark Starter, 2 years$2.49/mo (Sept. 2026)Unlimited30 days + 7-day trial
Surfshark Starter, 1 year$3.39/mo (Sept. 2026)Unlimited30 days + 7-day trial
Surfshark Starter, monthly$16.45 (Sept. 2026)Unlimited30 days + 7-day trial

Devices, Servers and Port Forwarding

On devices, Private Internet Access vs Surfshark is a tie, since both cover an unlimited number. On servers, PIA lists servers in 113 countries and Surfshark lists 4,500+ servers in 100 countries, so the two count different things.

Our PIA review says it offers port forwarding on every plan. Our sources do not say the same for Surfshark, so check before you buy if you need it; see our guide to a VPN with port forwarding. We have not measured speed for either, and both call their networks fast in their own marketing. Your distance to the server decides more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.

Ownership and Jurisdiction

PIA is based in the United States, part of the Five Eyes group, and has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019. Our review notes that Kape also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost and began life as Crossrider, a company known for bundling adware.

Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, which has no law forcing a VPN to keep connection logs but belongs to the Nine Eyes group. It merged with Nord Security’s holding company in 2022, though the two keep separate apps and networks; see our NordVPN vs Surfshark comparison.

Features Beyond the Basics

PIA describes its apps as 100% open source, a step it took in 2018, and offers a dedicated IP add-on, a free email breach monitor and 24/7 chat or email support. Our review adds that its interface has more settings than beginners need.

Surfshark’s Starter plan includes an ad blocker, Bypasser for split tunneling, Dynamic MultiHop, rotating IP and Alternative ID for throwaway sign-up details, and its pages list a dedicated IP and an Alternative Number as add-ons. Its Dausos protocol passed a first Cure53 review in 2026.

Choose Private Internet Access if…

  • You want port forwarding and open-source apps.
  • You value a no-logs claim tested in US federal court.
  • You want a lower month-to-month price.
  • You accept a US base and the Kape ownership history.

Choose Surfshark if…

  • You want audits you can check from public announcements.
  • You want a 7-day trial before the refund window starts.
  • You like ad blocking, MultiHop and Alternative ID in the same app.
  • You are comfortable with a Netherlands base and Nord Security ownership.

A Quick Way to Decide Between Private Internet Access vs Surfshark

In a Private Internet Access vs Surfshark decision, start with the evidence you can check yourself. If you want port forwarding, open-source apps or a court-tested claim, PIA settles it. If you want readable audit announcements, a trial and bundled extras, Surfshark settles it. If neither decides it, weigh where each company sits: the United States and Kape (PIA) against the Netherlands and Nord Security (Surfshark). For other matches, see Surfshark vs Mullvad, IPVanish vs Surfshark and our best VPN rankings.

Verdict: Private Internet Access vs Surfshark

Both are audited, unlimited-device services with documented records. In this Private Internet Access vs Surfshark comparison, PIA is the better pick for readers who want port forwarding, open-source apps and a court-tested claim, and Surfshark is the better pick for readers who want readable audits, a trial and a bundle of extras. Compare the renewal prices at checkout, and use the refund windows to test your choice. The detail behind each point is in our Private Internet Access review and Surfshark review.

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Private Internet Access better than Surfshark?

Neither wins on every point. PIA offers port forwarding, open-source apps and a no-logs claim tested in US federal court. Surfshark offers readable audit announcements, a 7-day trial and bundled extras. Pick on the points that matter to you.

Which is cheaper, PIA or Surfshark?

Both are cheap on long plans: $2.03 a month for PIA on 3 years plus 4 months on 16 November 2026, and $2.49 for Surfshark Starter on 2 years in September 2026. PIA is cheaper month to month, at $11.95 against $16.45.

How many devices do PIA and Surfshark allow?

Both allow an unlimited number of devices on one subscription.

Have PIA and Surfshark been audited for no logs?

Yes. PIA has had three Deloitte audits, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. Surfshark has had two Deloitte audits, in 2023 and 2025, plus reviews by Cure53 and SecuRing.

Did Surfshark hand over user data?

In April 2026 a court in Amsterdam issued a warrant, and Surfshark confirmed that an account existed and gave the payment details attached to it. It had no record of the person’s online activity.

Who owns PIA and Surfshark?

PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019. Surfshark has belonged to the same group as NordVPN, Nord Security, since 2022.

Sources