
TotalAV
Strong recent score, with caveats
From$99per year*
Total AV Plus, 4 devices
30-day money-back guarantee

Malwarebytes
Best for malware removal
From
60-day money-back guarantee
Prices are first-term prices read from each provider’s official U.S. page on November 14, 2026. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.
This TotalAV vs Malwarebytes comparison sets a tiered consumer suite next to a lighter, cleanup-focused tool. In AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round Malwarebytes scored 18 out of 18 and TotalAV 17.5, losing half a point on performance. AV-Comparatives separates them on false alarms: 5 for TotalAV and 39 for Malwarebytes in its February to May 2026 test, which cost Malwarebytes its award level. Price, devices and what each bundles decide the rest.
Short version: pick TotalAV if you want a simple tier ladder, a bundled VPN on higher tiers and the higher award. Pick Malwarebytes if you want a light program, strong adware cleanup and a free scanner, with a 60-day refund window. In the TotalAV vs Malwarebytes match-up both stop nearly everything.

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built
SecureGuides has not run its own malware tests, so this TotalAV vs Malwarebytes page relies on published labs and each company’s own pages. Lab figures come from AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 report and AV-Comparatives’ Real-World Protection Test for February to May 2026. We re-read TotalAV’s plan page and Malwarebytes’ pricing page on 15 November 2026, noting that Malwarebytes shows a device selector. Every source is linked at the end.
TotalAV vs Malwarebytes at a Glance
| TotalAV | Malwarebytes | |
|---|---|---|
| AV-TEST, Jul-Aug 2026 (protection / performance / usability) | 6 / 5.5 / 6 (17.5 of 18) | 6 / 6 / 6 (18 of 18) |
| AV-Comparatives, Feb-May 2026 | 99.0% protection, 5 false alarms, ADVANCED+ | 98.8% protection, 39 false alarms, STANDARD |
| Price | Regular $99 (4 devices), $129 (6), $149 (8); intro discounts | $44.99/yr (1 device) or $59.99 (3 devices), Standard |
| VPN | From the Internet Security tier upward, per our TotalAV vs Norton comparison | Included from the Plus plan ($79.98/yr, 3 devices) |
| Free option | None | Free on-demand scanner, plus Browser Guard |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days on annual plans, 14 on monthly | 60 days |
| Go to the provider | Visit TotalAVtotalav.com | Visit Malwarebytesmalwarebytes.com |
Lab scores are from the reports cited above. Prices are as listed on each company’s own page on 15 November 2026, during Black Friday promotions, and change often.
Lab Results: Two Labs, One Close Race
In AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round of 15 home products on Windows 11, Malwarebytes Premium 5.5 and 5.6 scored 6 out of 6 in all three categories. TotalAV 6.6 and 6.7, listed under its parent name Protected.net, scored 6 for protection and usability and 5.5 for performance. The half point is the only gap.
AV-Comparatives ran 400 attack scenarios between February and May 2026. TotalAV protected against 99.0% and earned the top ADVANCED+ award. Malwarebytes protected against 98.8%, a solid result, but fell to the entry-level STANDARD award because of its false alarms. Our Malwarebytes review explains why the two labs reached different verdicts.
False Alarms and What They Mean
AV-Comparatives counted 5 false alarms for TotalAV and 39 for Malwarebytes, against a field average of 8, and it lowers an award when the count is high. Malwarebytes takes a hard line on potentially unwanted programs, such as bundled toolbars and aggressive system cleaners, which is why people use it for cleanup and probably why it questions more borderline files.
Our TotalAV card notes that an earlier AV-Comparatives round in March 2025 recorded 28 false alarms, so one clean round is not a guarantee. TotalAV’s bigger user complaint is billing: our TotalAV vs Norton comparison notes recurring reports of unexpected renewal charges.
Price and Renewal: TotalAV vs Malwarebytes
| Plan | Price | Devices | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| TotalAV entry tier | $99/year regular | 4 | Intro discounts for new customers |
| TotalAV top tier | $149/year regular | 8 | 30-day refund on annual plans |
| Malwarebytes Standard | $44.99/yr (1 device) or $59.99/yr (3 devices) | 1 or 3 | Antivirus, scam and ad blocker |
| Malwarebytes Plus | $79.98/yr | 3 | Adds a VPN |
| Malwarebytes Total | $89.99/yr, marked down from $179.99 | 1 adult and 3 devices | Adds identity protection, $1M insurance |
Malwarebytes is cheaper at the entry level, especially for a single device at $44.99 a year, and gives 60 days to ask for a refund. TotalAV lists regular prices of $99 to $149 a year and says new customers may get introductory rates, with plans renewing at the rate in force at the time. Malwarebytes shows the three-device price on its main cards and the one-device price in a separate “fewer devices” offer, so check the device count before you compare.
For a household that needs eight devices, TotalAV’s top tier covers more than Malwarebytes’ cards. Either way, read the order summary and set a reminder for the renewal.
Features in TotalAV vs Malwarebytes
TotalAV organises its plans in three tiers, with extras such as a VPN and a password manager stepping up by tier.
Malwarebytes does fewer things on purpose. It has no firewall of its own, no parental controls and no password manager. What it has is a small footprint, a strong record at removing adware and unwanted programs, a scam and ad blocker, a VPN on the Plus plan and a free Browser Guard extension. The free download is only a manual scanner, so it does not protect you in real time.
Windows users should also weigh Microsoft Defender, which scored 99.0% with no false alarms in the same AV-Comparatives test; see our guide to whether Microsoft Defender is enough. For related comparisons, see Bitdefender vs Malwarebytes and Bitdefender vs TotalAV.
Privacy and Data Practices
Both rely on cloud data for detection and on account data for billing, and neither publishes a no-logs audit of the kind VPN companies do. TotalAV is operated by Protected.net, the name under which AV-TEST lists it. Read each privacy policy for what it collects.
Choose TotalAV if…
- You want the ADVANCED+ award and the lower false-alarm count.
- You want a simple tier ladder from four to eight devices.
- You want a bundled VPN and password manager stepping up by tier.
- You will read the order summary and cancel auto-renewal yourself.
Choose Malwarebytes if…
- You want a light program and strong cleanup of adware and unwanted software.
- You like a free scanner and a free browser extension alongside the paid version.
- You want a 60-day refund window to test it.
- You can live without a firewall, parental controls and a password manager.
A Quick Way to Decide Between TotalAV vs Malwarebytes
Start with what you need: a light cleanup tool and a free scanner point to Malwarebytes, while a tiered suite with a VPN and eight devices points to TotalAV. If neither decides it, the false-alarm gap, 5 against 39, favours the quieter TotalAV, and the 60-day refund favours Malwarebytes. For the wider field, see our Norton vs Malwarebytes comparison.
Verdict: TotalAV vs Malwarebytes
Both are well-tested products. In this TotalAV vs Malwarebytes comparison, TotalAV is the better pick for a household that wants a simple suite with a VPN and the higher award, and Malwarebytes is the better pick for someone who wants a light, focused tool, strong cleanup and a long refund window. Read our Malwarebytes review for more on Malwarebytes, and use the refund windows to test whichever you choose.
TotalAV vs Malwarebytes: Frequently Asked Questions
Is TotalAV better than Malwarebytes?
Not on every point. Malwarebytes scored 18 out of 18 in AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round against 17.5 for TotalAV, but TotalAV had 5 false alarms in AV-Comparatives’ February to May 2026 test against 39 for Malwarebytes.
Which is cheaper, TotalAV or Malwarebytes?
Malwarebytes at the entry level: $44.99 a year for one device and $59.99 for three on 15 November 2026, against TotalAV’s regular $99 to $149 with intro discounts. Check the renewal rate for both.
Does Malwarebytes replace Microsoft Defender?
The paid Premium plan becomes your main antivirus. The free version is only an on-demand scanner, so Defender keeps running next to it.
Which has the longer money-back guarantee?
Malwarebytes, at 60 days. TotalAV gives 30 days on annual plans and 14 on monthly plans.
Do TotalAV and Malwarebytes include a VPN?
Both on higher tiers: TotalAV from its Internet Security tier upward, and Malwarebytes from its Plus plan.
Do I need either on Windows 11?
Not necessarily. Microsoft Defender scored 99.0% with no false alarms in the same AV-Comparatives test.


