ExpressVPN
Best for speed & streaming
- 28 published third-party audits
- A 2017 police server seizure found no logs

Proton VPN
- Free plan with no data cap
- No-logs policy audited every year since 2022
Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.
This ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN comparison sets two very different privacy records side by side. ExpressVPN can point to 28 published audits and a server that Turkish police seized in 2017 without finding anything on a user. Proton VPN can point to a yearly audit, open-source apps, 458 Swiss court orders that produced no user data and a non-profit owner. The question is which kind of evidence you trust, and whether you will pay for ExpressVPN once the introductory price ends.
Short version: ExpressVPN is the stronger pick if you want the longest audit list and a design tested by a real seizure, and you are willing to track the renewal price. Proton VPN is the stronger pick if you want a free plan, open code and an owner that cannot easily be sold. Our ExpressVPN review and Proton VPN review hold the detail behind each point.

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built
SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests, so this page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources already behind our two reviews: ExpressVPN’s Trust Center and 2025 KPMG summary, its transparency figures, the public reporting on the 2017 Turkish seizure, the US Justice Department case that involved one of its former executives and its September 2026 order page; and Proton’s audit announcement, its transparency report to June 2026, the Swiss surveillance reporting and its October 2026 prices. Where a source does not cover a point, this page says so.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN at a Glance
| ExpressVPN | Proton VPN | |
|---|---|---|
| Base | British Virgin Islands | Switzerland |
| Owner | Kape Technologies since 2021 (also owns PIA and CyberGhost) | Proton AG, majority held by the non-profit Proton Foundation |
| Free plan | No | Yes, no data cap (1 device, 10 countries) |
| Price, 2-year plan | $2.99/month (Basic), renews at $99.95/year | $3.49/month (VPN Plus) |
| Price, month to month | From $12.99 | $9.99 (VPN Plus) |
| Devices | 10 to 14, by plan | 10 (free plan: 1) |
| Network | 113 countries | 20,000+ servers in more than 140 countries |
| Audits | 28 published; KPMG no-logs in 2023 and 2025, PwC in 2019 | Securitum every year, 2022 to 2026 |
| Real-world record | 2017 Turkish seizure found no user data | 458 Swiss court orders since 2017, no identifying data handed over |
| Open source | Lightway protocol | All apps |
| Default protocol | Lightway (own, with post-quantum protection) | WireGuard |
| Points to weigh | 2021 Project Raven case, Kape ownership, large renewal jump | Unresolved Swiss surveillance proposal |
| Go to the provider | Visit ExpressVPNexpressvpn.com | Visit Proton VPNprotonvpn.com |
Prices as listed on ExpressVPN’s order page in September 2026 and Proton’s pricing page in October 2026. Both change offers often, so confirm before you buy.
No-Logs Evidence: A Real Seizure Versus Yearly Audits
ExpressVPN’s strongest card is an event nobody arranged. After the December 2016 assassination of Russia’s ambassador to Turkey, investigators traced a VPN login to an ExpressVPN server, and Turkish authorities seized it. According to TorrentFreak and Comparitech, they found nothing that identified the user, and the company had nothing to hand over when asked. Its servers run from RAM only under a design called TrustedServer, so switching one off erases everything on it. ExpressVPN’s own transparency figures for the first half of 2026 list 137 requests for user information and more than 1.3 million copyright notices, with nothing disclosed.
Its Trust Center lists 28 published audits, but they test different things. The no-logs work is PwC in 2019 and KPMG in 2023 and again as of 28 February 2025. The 2025 KPMG report is an ISAE 3000 Type I report, which checks that controls were designed properly on one date rather than that they kept working over months. The rest are code audits: Lightway four times since 2021, plus the apps. That is a real assurance, but narrower than a headline of “audited no-logs” suggests.
Proton VPN’s record is less varied but steadier. Securitum has audited its no-logs claims every year from 2022 to 2026, and the 2026 audit found no sign that the servers examined log browsing activity, DNS queries or traffic contents. Its transparency report adds the real-world side: 458 legally binding Swiss orders for user data since 2017, 47 of them in the first half of 2026, and identifying information handed over in none. Both companies have an audit trail and a real-world result, in different forms, and neither is something we have verified ourselves.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: Ownership and History
In 2021 ExpressVPN was bought by Kape Technologies, which also owns Private Internet Access and CyberGhost. Kape began as Crossrider, a company tied to adware, and that past still colours how some people see its brands. Also in 2021, the US Department of Justice announced a settlement with three former US intelligence operatives who had worked on hacking operations for the United Arab Emirates.
One of them, Daniel Gericke, was ExpressVPN’s chief information officer at the time. ExpressVPN said it knew of his UAE work only in general terms when it hired him and kept him on, and it published an official response. Nothing in the case involved ExpressVPN’s own systems, and its audits since the sale are the best evidence that operations have not changed. These are questions of judgement, not a leak or a broken promise.
Proton’s structure is the opposite kind of story. In 2024 its founders gave their shares to a new non-profit, the Proton Foundation, now the main shareholder, and no change of control can happen without its agreement. A sale to a larger group is therefore very unlikely, which is unusual in a market where many brands have changed hands.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN Jurisdiction: Virgin Islands or Switzerland
ExpressVPN is based in the British Virgin Islands, outside the Five Eyes alliance and without mandatory data retention laws, according to our review. Proton is based in Geneva, outside the EU and the Five Eyes, where current law does not require a VPN provider to keep connection logs.
Switzerland carries a caveat that the Virgin Islands do not: in 2025 the Swiss government proposed rules that would have required online services with more than 5,000 users to store metadata such as IP addresses for six months. Proton’s chief executive said it would leave Switzerland if that passed, and the company began moving part of its infrastructure to Germany and Norway. As of 2026 the proposal is on hold with no date for a second consultation, so nothing has changed for users yet.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: Pricing and the Renewal Jump
| Plan | 2-year price | First bill | Renews at | Devices |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ExpressVPN Basic | $2.99/mo | $83.72 (28 months) | $99.95/year | 10 |
| ExpressVPN Advanced | $4.19/mo | $117.32 (28 months) | $119.95/year | 12 |
| ExpressVPN Pro | $7.19/mo | $201.32 (28 months) | $199.95/year | 14 |
| Proton VPN Plus | $3.49/mo | – | Check Proton’s page | 10 |
| Proton VPN Free | $0 | – | – | 1 |
The first term favours ExpressVPN on paper: Basic works out to about $36 a year, including four bonus months, against $3.49 a month for Proton VPN Plus. The picture changes at renewal. ExpressVPN Basic renews at $99.95 a year, close to three times its first-term rate, which is one of the larger jumps in the market. Our sources for Proton do not state its renewal rates, so check them on its pricing page. Month to month, ExpressVPN starts at $12.99 and VPN Plus costs $9.99. If you only want to try a service, Proton’s free plan costs nothing, while ExpressVPN offers a 30-day money-back guarantee for new customers.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: The Free Plan Question
Proton VPN’s free plan has no data cap, no ads and the same no-logs policy as the paid tiers. The limits are convenience ones: one device, servers in 10 countries, no choice of server, no torrenting and no extras such as NetShield or Secure Core. It suits protecting a laptop or phone on public Wi-Fi, and is a poor fit for streaming one country’s library. ExpressVPN has nothing equivalent. See our guide to whether free VPNs are safe for why most free services are a worse deal.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: Features and Protocols
ExpressVPN runs on TrustedServer and its own Lightway protocol, built as a smaller, faster alternative to OpenVPN. Lightway is open source and now includes post-quantum protection, aimed at traffic recorded today that could be decrypted later. Network Lock is its kill switch, split tunneling works on Windows, macOS, Android and routers, and the company also sells Aircove routers and a router app. Some locations, Turkey included, are virtual: you get local IP addresses routed through servers in another country.
Proton VPN uses WireGuard by default and open-sources every app. Paid plans add Secure Core, which routes traffic through a first server in Switzerland, Iceland or Sweden, NetShield for ads, trackers and malware domains, Stealth for networks that block VPNs, Tor over VPN, and P2P servers with port forwarding. Secure Core costs some speed, so switch it on only when you need it.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: Speed, Streaming and China
We have not measured speed for either. As noted in our reviews, independent reviewers usually place ExpressVPN among the fastest services, trading first place with NordVPN, and Proton VPN just behind the leaders. For most home connections the gap is small, and your distance to the server and your provider decide more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.
ExpressVPN has a long reputation with Netflix and BBC iPlayer, and Proton’s paid plans are generally reported to work with major streaming services; both shift as platforms update their blocks, and Proton’s free plan does not let you pick a country. Our best VPN for Netflix guide compares the options.
For China, ExpressVPN turns on obfuscation automatically and is widely reported to work much of the time, with drops around sensitive dates; its website is blocked there, so install it before travelling. If you are weighing Proton for the same trip, read our guide to whether Proton VPN works in China.
Choose ExpressVPN if…
- You want the longest list of published audits and a no-logs design already tested by a real seizure.
- You want a simple app that behaves the same across many countries, or a router-based setup for the whole home.
- You need up to 14 devices and will pay for the Pro tier.
- You will note the renewal date and compare offers before it arrives.
- You are comfortable with the Kape ownership and the Project Raven history.
Choose Proton VPN if…
- You want a free plan, or one to try before paying.
- You want open-source apps and an owner that cannot easily be bought.
- You already use Proton Mail or Proton Pass and want one account.
- You would rather avoid a large renewal jump and a corporate owner with a past you are uneasy about.
- You can live with the open question around Swiss surveillance law.
A Quick Way to Settle ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN
Start with what you trust more as proof: a real seizure plus a long audit list (ExpressVPN), or yearly audits, court orders that came back empty and open code (Proton VPN). Then check ownership: if Kape or the Project Raven case bothers you, Proton is the cleaner fit. Finally price it for three years, not one, since ExpressVPN’s renewal changes the maths. For the wider field see our best VPN rankings, and for other Proton matchups NordVPN vs Proton VPN and Mullvad vs Proton VPN. The original two-way test is in NordVPN vs ExpressVPN.
Verdict: ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN
Both back their claims with evidence you can read. ExpressVPN has the deeper paper trail and one outcome nobody could stage, and it earns its reputation on that, at a price that rises sharply after the first term and with ownership some users will not accept.
Proton VPN is cheaper to start, free if you need it, open to inspection and structurally hard to sell, with Swiss law as its one open question. If audits and a seizure record decide it for you, choose ExpressVPN and plan for renewal. If ownership, openness and a free tier matter more, choose Proton VPN, and use the refund windows to test either.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN comes down to which proof you trust and what you will pay after the first term: ExpressVPN has the longer audit list and a real seizure record, while Proton VPN has a free plan, open apps and a non-profit owner. Check the renewal price on each site before you decide ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN.
ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN: Frequently Asked Questions
Is ExpressVPN better than Proton VPN?
Neither wins everywhere. ExpressVPN has the longest audit list and a server design that held up in a real police seizure, but it costs far more after the first term and sits inside Kape Technologies. Proton VPN has a free plan, open-source apps, a non-profit owner and cheaper entry pricing, but a smaller audit history and an open question around Swiss surveillance law.
Which has stronger proof of no logs, ExpressVPN or Proton VPN?
They prove it differently. ExpressVPN lists 28 published audits, including KPMG no-logs assessments in 2023 and 2025, and in 2017 Turkish authorities seized one of its servers and found nothing that identified the user. Proton VPN has a yearly Securitum audit from 2022 to 2026 and says it handed over identifying data in none of 458 Swiss court orders since 2017.
Does ExpressVPN or Proton VPN have a free plan?
Only Proton VPN. Its free plan has no data cap and no ads, but covers one device, servers in 10 countries and no choice of server. ExpressVPN has no free plan, only a 30-day money-back guarantee for new customers.
Which is cheaper, ExpressVPN or Proton VPN?
On the 2-year term ExpressVPN Basic was $2.99 a month and Proton VPN Plus $3.49 in 2026, but ExpressVPN Basic renews at $99.95 a year, about three times its first-term rate. Month to month, ExpressVPN starts at $12.99 against $9.99 for VPN Plus. Check the renewal rate on each site before you commit.
Who owns ExpressVPN and Proton VPN?
ExpressVPN has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2021, the same group that owns Private Internet Access and CyberGhost. Proton VPN belongs to Proton AG, whose main shareholder has been the non-profit Proton Foundation since 2024.
How many devices do ExpressVPN and Proton VPN cover?
ExpressVPN covers 10 devices on Basic, 12 on Advanced and 14 on Pro. Proton VPN Plus covers 10, and the free plan covers one.
What is the main difference in ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN?
ExpressVPN has the longer audit list and a real seizure record but a large renewal jump. Proton VPN has a free plan, open apps and a non-profit owner.
Sources
- ExpressVPN: Trust Center (published audits)
- ExpressVPN: 2025 KPMG no-logs policy assessment
- TorrentFreak: VPN server seized to investigate the assassination of the Russian ambassador
- Comparitech: ExpressVPN server seized in Turkey verifies no-logs claim
- ExpressVPN: response on Daniel Gericke
- Proton VPN: no-logs audit
- Proton VPN: transparency report
- heise online: Proton relocates parts of its infrastructure from Switzerland
- Proton: the Proton non-profit foundation

