Skip to content

Surfshark vs Proton VPN 2026: Which VPN Is Better?

Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.

This Surfshark vs Proton VPN comparison starts from what each company can actually show. Surfshark has two Deloitte no-logs assessments, unlimited devices and one of the lowest long-term prices among audited VPNs. Proton VPN has five yearly audits, 458 Swiss court orders that produced no identifying data, open-source apps and a non-profit owner. The right pick depends on whether you value price and a big household allowance, or transparency and a free plan.

Short version: pick Surfshark if you want to cover many devices cheaply. Pick Proton VPN if you want a free plan you can trust, published code and an owner that cannot easily be bought. In the Surfshark vs Proton VPN match-up both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans, so you can test either on your own connection.

Surfshark vs Proton VPN comparison card with both VPN logos

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built

SecureGuides has not run its own speed or detection tests for this page, so this Surfshark vs Proton VPN page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our Surfshark review and our Proton VPN review: each company’s own audit announcements and transparency reports, plus the prices listed on their sites. We re-read both transparency reports and Proton’s pricing page in November 2026 to check the figures used here. Every source is linked at the end.

Surfshark vs Proton VPN at a Glance

SurfsharkProton VPN
No-logs checksDeloitte in 2023 and 2025; Cure53 and SecuRing reviewsYearly audit by Securitum, 2022 to 2026
Real-world recordQuarterly transparency reports; one Dutch warrant in April 2026 (payment details only)458 Swiss court orders since 2017, no identifying data handed over
Free planNoYes (1 device, 10 countries)
Price, 2-year plan$2.49/month (Starter)$3.49/month (VPN Plus)
Price, month to month$16.45 (Starter)$9.99 (VPN Plus)
DevicesUnlimited10 (free plan: 1)
Servers4,500+ in 100 countries20,000+ in more than 140 countries
AppsAudited; no source code published in our sourcesOpen source on all platforms
BaseNetherlandsSwitzerland
OwnerNord Security groupProton AG, majority held by the non-profit Proton Foundation
Go to the providerVisit Surfsharksurfshark.comVisit Proton VPNprotonvpn.com

Surfshark prices are from its plan comparison in September 2026 and Proton prices from its pricing page in October 2026. Both adjust offers often and charge more at renewal, so confirm before you buy.

No-Logs Evidence: Two Deloitte Reports Versus Five Yearly Audits

Deloitte checked Surfshark’s no-logs policy in 2023 and again in 2025. The 2025 work produced an ISAE 3000 reasonable assurance report, the stronger of the two levels an auditor can give, covering server configuration, deployment and privacy settings (Surfshark’s announcement). Other firms looked at other layers. Cure53 audited the infrastructure in 2021 and 2026, and SecuRing tested the apps, browser extensions and infrastructure in 2025. Every Surfshark server runs from RAM only, so a reboot wipes it.

Proton VPN has used a single firm, the Polish company Securitum, every year from 2022 to 2026. Its fifth audit found no sign that the servers examined log browsing activity, DNS queries or traffic contents, and confirmed that the policy is the same on free and paid plans. Repeating the same method each year makes a quiet change to logging harder to hide.

Neither record is stronger on paper in every respect. Surfshark has more separate firms looking at more layers. Proton has more years in a row from one auditor. Both are clean, and both come from outside companies rather than the VPN itself.

What Each Company Did When Authorities Asked

Audits show a setup was checked. Transparency reports show what happened under pressure, and here the two differ. Proton says in its transparency report that Swiss courts have sent it 458 legally binding orders since 2017, including 47 from January to June 2026, and that it could not provide identifying information in any of them.

Surfshark’s latest report, for July to September 2026, lists 23 inquiries from government institutions, no warrants, no national security letters and no gag orders, and says none led to the disclosure of data about users’ online activity. The earlier April 2026 case is the more instructive one. A court in Amsterdam issued a warrant, and Surfshark confirmed that the account existed and handed over the payment details attached to it. It could not say what that person did online, because it keeps no such record.

These two stories are not like for like. Proton’s figure is a long run of orders answered with nothing identifying. Surfshark’s case shows the limit of any paid VPN: it knows who pays. If being identified as a customer is your worry, pay with a method that leaves little behind, whichever service you choose. Our Surfshark review covers that case in detail.

Jurisdiction: Netherlands or Switzerland

Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, which has no law forcing a VPN to keep connection logs but belongs to the Nine Eyes intelligence-sharing group. Proton is based in Geneva. Switzerland is outside the EU and the Five Eyes, and its current law does not require a VPN provider to keep connection logs. Foreign requests go through Swiss authorities first, which is why all 458 orders in Proton’s report came that way.

Switzerland is not a guarantee, though. In 2021 a Swiss court order led Proton Mail, the email service rather than the VPN, to record the IP address of a French climate activist. And in 2025 the Swiss government proposed rules that would have required online services above 5,000 users to store metadata such as IP addresses for six months. Proton said it would leave Switzerland if the proposal passed in that form, and began moving part of its infrastructure to Germany and Norway. As of 2026 the proposal is on hold pending a second consultation with no fixed date.

Price and Devices: Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Plan2 years1 yearMonthlyDevices
Surfshark Starter$2.49/mo$3.39/mo$16.45Unlimited
Proton VPN Plus$3.49/mo$4.49/mo$9.9910
Proton VPN Free$0––1

Surfshark is cheaper on the long plans, and the device allowance widens the gap. Count the phones, laptops, tablet, smart TV and games console in a family home and ten runs out fast. Surfshark sets no limit, though it is still one account, so it suits a household better than friends splitting a plan across separate homes. Surfshark’s own page spreads its 2-year price over 27 months (24 plus three extra). Its One and One+ tiers add antivirus, data-leak alerts and a data-removal service.

Proton wins on month-to-month cost: $9.99 against $16.45. Proton’s bundle, Proton Unlimited at $7.99 a month on a 2-year term, adds encrypted email, storage, a calendar and the Proton Pass password manager, which helps if you would pay for those tools anyway.

Promotions muddy the picture. When we checked Proton’s page in mid-November 2026 it showed a Black Friday coupon: VPN Plus at $2.99 a month for the first 12 months, then renewing at $83.88 a year, or $6.99 a month. Surfshark’s page shows prices in your local currency, so the dollar figures above may not match what you see. Whichever you pick, read the renewal price before you pay.

The Free Plan Question in Surfshark vs Proton VPN

This is where the two differ most. Proton VPN’s free plan has no data cap, shows no ads and runs under the same no-logs policy as the paid plans. The limits are about convenience: one device, servers in 10 countries that the app chooses for you, medium speed, and no streaming, P2P or ad blocker. It suits one job well, which is protecting a laptop or phone on public Wi-Fi. Our guide to whether free VPNs are safe explains why most free services are a worse deal.

Surfshark has no free plan. It offers a 30-day money-back guarantee on every plan and a 7-day free trial through the Google Play and Apple app stores, which lets you check its speed on your own line before committing.

Network, Protocols and Speed: Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Surfshark runs 4,500+ servers in 100 countries. Proton VPN lists 20,000+ servers in more than 140 countries, so it reaches more places. For most people connecting to a nearby server in a major country the difference is invisible. It matters if you need an uncommon country or live far from the usual hubs.

Surfshark offers standard WireGuard and Dausos, a protocol it built from scratch with AEGIS-256X2 encryption, which passed its first independent review by Cure53 in 2026. New protocols have had less scrutiny than WireGuard or OpenVPN, so WireGuard remains the safer default. Proton uses WireGuard by default.

We do not publish a speed verdict because we have not measured one. Your distance to the server, your provider and the time of day usually decide more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows. The trial and refund windows exist so you can test on your own connection.

Extra Features in Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Surfshark’s toolkit covers the basics well: CleanWeb blocks ads, trackers, malicious sites and cookie pop-ups, Bypasser is its split tunneling, MultiHop routes through two servers, and Camouflage Mode hides VPN use on networks that block it. Alternative ID generates a separate name, email address and phone number for sign-ups, which keeps spam and breaches away from your real details. A kill switch is available on every platform.

Proton VPN’s paid plans add Secure Core, which routes traffic through a first server in Switzerland, Iceland or Sweden before it exits in your chosen country, and NetShield, which blocks ads, trackers and malware domains. Stealth is its obfuscated protocol, Tor over VPN reaches .onion sites, and P2P servers support port forwarding. Secure Core and Tor over VPN cost some speed, so switch them on only when you need them.

Ownership

Surfshark merged with Nord Security’s holding company in 2022. The two keep separate apps, networks and plans, so a NordVPN vs Surfshark choice is between two products from one group. Our source for the merger is Surfshark’s own announcement.

In 2024 Proton’s founders gave their shares to a newly created non-profit, the Proton Foundation, now the company’s main shareholder. No change of control can happen without the foundation’s agreement, which makes a sale to a larger group very unlikely. See also our NordVPN vs Proton VPN comparison.

Streaming: Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Both services are generally reported to work with Netflix and other major platforms in the main regions on their paid plans. Access shifts whenever a platform updates its blocks, for every provider, and Proton’s free plan does not let you choose a country. If streaming is your main reason to buy, compare both against the options in our guide to the best VPN for Netflix.

Choose Surfshark if…

  • You cover many devices, or a whole household, on one account.
  • You want the lowest long-term price from an audited VPN.
  • You like having ad blocking, MultiHop and Alternative ID in the same app.
  • You are comfortable with a Netherlands base and with audits as the proof, rather than public source code.

Choose Proton VPN if…

  • You want a free plan you can trust, or a free tier to try before paying.
  • You care most about open-source apps, transparency and who owns the company.
  • You already use Proton Mail or Proton Pass and would like one account.
  • You accept the open question around Swiss surveillance law, given Proton’s stated plan to move rather than comply.

A Quick Way to Decide Between Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Start with devices. If you need more than ten, Surfshark settles it. Then ask whether you want a free option; if so, only Proton VPN has one. If neither applies, decide what you trust more as evidence: two Deloitte reports plus other reviews (Surfshark), or five yearly audits plus a record of empty court orders and an owner that cannot be bought (Proton VPN). For the wider field, see our best VPN rankings.

Verdict: Surfshark vs Proton VPN

Both are well-documented services, and neither needs an invented test to make its case. In this Surfshark vs Proton VPN comparison, Surfshark is the better pick for a busy household on a budget. Proton VPN is the better pick for anyone who puts transparency, open code and ownership first, and who accepts the open question around Swiss law. Read our Surfshark review and Proton VPN review for the detail behind each point, and use the refund windows to test whichever you choose.

Surfshark vs Proton VPN: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Surfshark better than Proton VPN?

Neither wins on every point. Surfshark costs less on a long plan and has no device limit. Proton VPN has a free plan with no data cap, open-source apps, a non-profit owner and 458 Swiss court orders that produced no identifying data. Pick on the points that matter to you.

Does Surfshark or Proton VPN have a free plan?

Only Proton VPN. Its free plan covers one device, with servers in 10 countries that the app picks at random, and it leaves out streaming, P2P and the ad blocker. Surfshark has no free plan, only a 30-day money-back guarantee and a 7-day trial through the Google Play and Apple app stores.

Which has stronger proof of no logs?

They prove it differently. Surfshark has two Deloitte assessments (2023 and 2025), plus Cure53 and SecuRing security reviews. Proton VPN has a yearly Securitum audit from 2022 to 2026 and a record of Swiss court orders answered with no identifying information. Audits check the setup; a transparency report shows what happened when authorities asked.

Did Surfshark hand over user data to the police?

In April 2026 a court in Amsterdam issued a warrant, and Surfshark confirmed that an account existed and gave the payment details attached to it. It had no record of the person’s online activity to hand over. Its report for July to September 2026 lists 23 government inquiries and no warrants.

Which is cheaper, Surfshark or Proton VPN?

On the 2-year term Surfshark Starter was listed at $2.49 a month in September 2026 against $3.49 for Proton VPN Plus in October 2026. Month to month it flips: $16.45 for Surfshark against $9.99 for Proton. Both renew at a higher price, so check the renewal rate and any current promotion before buying.

How many devices do Surfshark and Proton VPN cover?

Surfshark covers an unlimited number on every plan. Proton VPN Plus covers ten, and the free plan covers one.

Who owns Surfshark and Proton VPN?

Surfshark has belonged to the same group as NordVPN, Nord Security, since 2022, though the two run separate networks. Proton VPN belongs to Proton AG, whose main shareholder has been the non-profit Proton Foundation since 2024.

Sources