
NordVPN
Best overall value
- Six independent no-logs assessments
- NordLynx protocol, built on WireGuard

Private Internet Access
- No-logs record tested twice in US federal court
- Three Deloitte audits and open-source apps
Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.
This NordVPN vs Private Internet Access comparison puts two audited VPNs side by side that prove their no-logs claims in different ways. NordVPN has six outside assessments since 2018. Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, has three Deloitte audits, two US federal court cases and quarterly transparency reports. PIA also allows unlimited devices and keeps port forwarding, while NordVPN caps devices at ten and offers more specialty servers.
Short version: pick NordVPN if you want the longest audit record, a polished app and specialty servers such as Double VPN. Pick PIA if you want unlimited devices, open-source apps, port forwarding and a lower long-term price. In the NordVPN vs Private Internet Access match-up, both rest on documented evidence rather than on speed claims.

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built
SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests for this page, so this NordVPN vs Private Internet Access page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our NordVPN review and our Private Internet Access review, plus pages we re-read in November 2026: NordVPN’s pricing and servers pages on 15 November, and PIA’s home and checkout pages on 16 November. Every source is linked at the end.
NordVPN vs Private Internet Access at a Glance
| NordVPN | PIA | |
|---|---|---|
| No-logs checks | 6 assessments since 2018 (PwC, then Deloitte), latest in late 2025 | 3 Deloitte audits: 2022, 2024, 2025 |
| Real-world record | 2018 server breach, disclosed in October 2019 | US federal subpoenas in 2016 and 2018 that produced no user data; quarterly transparency reports |
| Price, longest plan | $2.99/month (Basic, 27 months), renews at $139.08/year | $2.03/month (3 years plus 4 months, Nov. 2026) |
| Month to month | Not re-read; $14.99 in our September check | $11.95 |
| Devices | 10 | Unlimited |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days for new users |
| Servers | Thousands in 225 locations (NordVPN’s wording) | Servers in 113 countries |
| Open-source apps | Linux app only (since 2023) | Apps are open source, per our review |
| Base | Panama | United States, with a UK-headquartered parent |
| Owner | Nord Security (also owns Surfshark) | Kape Technologies since 2019 (also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost) |
Prices are as listed on each company’s own pages in November 2026, during Black Friday promotions, and change often. PIA’s checkout page also showed a mid-length plan at $3.99 a month, which we have not labelled. Confirm the renewal price before you buy.
No-Logs Evidence: Six Assessments Versus Court Cases and Three Audits
NordVPN’s no-logs claims were reviewed by PwC in 2018 and 2020, then by Deloitte in 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025. The sixth round ran from 10 November to 12 December 2025 under the ISAE 3000 standard (TechRadar’s report). Two Big Four firms over eight years is one of the longest records in the industry.
PIA has two kinds of evidence. Deloitte reviewed it in 2022, 2024 and 2025, each under ISAE 3000, with the 2025 round adding its token-based dedicated IP system and incident-response practices. And its no-logs claim was tested in US federal court: in 2016 the FBI sent a subpoena in a bomb-threat case and in 2018 another came up in a hacking case, and in both PIA could provide only a cluster of IP addresses, not a user, according to court documents reported by TorrentFreak. Both cases predate the 2019 sale to Kape, so they show how PIA worked then.
NordVPN has a documented weak point too: in March 2018 an attacker used a remote management tool, left open by a hosting company in Finland, to take an expired certificate key from one server. There were no activity logs to take, but NordVPN did not disclose the incident until October 2019. It then moved to RAM-only servers and committed to repeated audits.
Transparency Reports and Ownership
PIA publishes a quarterly transparency report. Our review notes that the Q2 2026 edition lists 19 legal requests, four subpoenas, two warrants, seven other government or civil requests and six foreign or informal ones, and that PIA handed over nothing in any of them. These are self-published, so they are the weakest layer, but they sit next to the court record and the audits.
Ownership differs sharply. NordVPN belongs to Nord Security, which also owns Surfshark. PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019, and our review notes that Kape also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost and began life as Crossrider, a company known for bundling adware. For jurisdiction, NordVPN is in Panama, outside the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes; PIA is based in the United States, which is part of the Five Eyes.
Price and Devices: NordVPN vs Private Internet Access
PIA is cheaper on its longest plan and has no device limit, which suits a large household. NordVPN’s Basic price during the Black Friday offer is close, but it renews at $139.08 a year, which is more than double its first-term monthly equivalent. PIA’s page does not state its renewal price in the text we read, so check the order summary before you pay.
Both give new customers 30 days to ask for a refund. A three-year commitment is a long trust horizon whichever you choose, so use the refund window to test it.
| Plan | Price | Devices | Refund |
|---|---|---|---|
| NordVPN Basic | $2.99/mo for 27 months ($80.73); renews at $139.08/year | 10 | 30 days |
| PIA, longest plan | $2.03/mo (3 years plus 4 months) | Unlimited | 30 days, new users |
| PIA, monthly | $11.95 | Unlimited | 30 days, new users |
Network, Protocols and Speed
NordVPN says only that it runs thousands of servers in 225 locations. PIA says it offers servers in 113 countries. NordVPN uses NordLynx, its version of WireGuard that avoids storing which user holds which internal address; PIA runs RAM-only servers, according to our review.
We do not publish a speed verdict because we have not measured one. Your distance to the server, your provider and the time of day usually decide more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.
Extra Features in NordVPN vs Private Internet Access
NordVPN offers Double VPN, Onion Over VPN, obfuscated servers, P2P servers, a dedicated IP address as an add-on, Threat Protection and Meshnet. Its app is the more polished of the two for beginners.
PIA offers port forwarding on every plan, which our review notes NordVPN and ExpressVPN removed, open-source apps and many settings for power users. Our review also says its interface is busier than NordVPN’s and has more settings than beginners need.
Choose NordVPN if…
- You want the longest audit record, with six assessments by two Big Four firms.
- You want a polished app and specialty servers such as Double VPN.
- You prefer a Panama base outside the Five Eyes.
- You will track the renewal date, because the price jumps after the first term.
Choose Private Internet Access if…
- You want unlimited devices on one plan.
- You want port forwarding and open-source apps.
- You value a no-logs record tested in US federal court.
- You accept a US base and the Kape ownership history.
A Quick Way to Decide Between NordVPN vs Private Internet Access
Start with devices and port forwarding: PIA settles it if you need unlimited devices or inbound ports. If you want the longest audit record and a polished app, NordVPN settles it. If neither decides it, weigh where each company sits: Panama and Nord Security (NordVPN) against the United States and Kape (PIA). For the wider field, see our best VPN rankings and the NordVPN vs ExpressVPN comparison.
Verdict: NordVPN vs Private Internet Access
Both are audited services with documented records. In this NordVPN vs Private Internet Access comparison, NordVPN is the better pick for anyone who wants the longest audit record, a polished app and extras, and PIA is the better pick for a large household, a power user or anyone who wants port forwarding and open-source apps at a low long-term price. Read our NordVPN review and Private Internet Access review for the detail behind each point, and use the 30-day refund windows to test whichever you choose.
NordVPN vs Private Internet Access: Frequently Asked Questions
Is NordVPN better than Private Internet Access?
Neither wins on every point. NordVPN has the longest audit record, a polished app and specialty servers. PIA has unlimited devices, port forwarding, open-source apps and two US federal court cases behind its no-logs claim. Pick on the points that matter to you.
Which is cheaper, NordVPN or PIA?
PIA on its longest plan: $2.03 a month on 3 years plus 4 months on 16 November 2026, against $2.99 for NordVPN Basic on 27 months. NordVPN renews at $139.08 a year, so check the renewal price for both.
How many devices do NordVPN and PIA cover?
NordVPN covers ten at once. PIA says one plan covers unlimited simultaneous connections.
Have both been audited for no logs?
Yes. NordVPN has had six assessments since 2018 by PwC and then Deloitte. PIA has had three Deloitte audits, in 2022, 2024 and 2025, as our review reports.
Who owns NordVPN and PIA?
NordVPN belongs to Nord Security, which also owns Surfshark. PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019, which our reviews say also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost.
Does PIA have port forwarding?
Yes, on every plan, according to our review, which notes that NordVPN and ExpressVPN removed it.
Sources
- TechRadar: independent auditors confirm NordVPN never stores your data, sixth assessment
- NordVPN: pricing
- NordVPN: servers
- Private Internet Access: home
- Private Internet Access: plans and pricing
- Private Internet Access: transparency report
- TorrentFreak: VPN providers’ no-logging claims tested in an FBI case (2016)


