Skip to content

Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN 2026: Which VPN Is Better?

Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.

This Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN comparison puts an unlimited-device VPN with a US court record next to a Swiss one with a free plan. Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, has three Deloitte audits, two US federal court cases and a low long-term price. Proton VPN has a no-logs audit by Securitum every year since 2022, a free plan with no data cap and an owner built to resist a sale. The gap between them is wider than the price tag suggests.

Short version: pick PIA if you have many devices and want the lowest long-term price with port forwarding. Pick Proton VPN if you want a free plan to try first, a larger network, a yearly audit from the same firm and a Swiss base with a non-profit as main shareholder. In the Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN match-up, we have not measured speed for either.

Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN comparison card with both logos

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built

SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests for this page, so this Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our Private Internet Access review and our Proton VPN review, plus pages we re-read in November 2026: PIA’s plans page and transparency report on 16 November, Proton VPN’s pricing page on 16 November, and Proton’s no-logs audit post, updated 16 June 2026, and transparency report, updated 14 July 2026. Both companies list dollar prices; both run promotions, so we label them. Every source is linked at the end.

Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN at a Glance

PIAProton VPN
No-logs checks3 Deloitte audits: 2022, 2024, 2025Securitum every year, 2022 to 2026 (fifth audit); apps audited by SEC Consult in 2020
Real-world recordUS federal court cases in 2016 and 2018 produced no user data; Q3 2026 report lists 9 requests, no logs produced458 Swiss court orders since 2017; all 47 in the first half of 2026 denied
Free planNo; 30-day money-back guarantee for new subscribersYes, no data cap: 1 device, 10 countries chosen for you, no P2P or streaming
Price, first term$2.03/month for 3 years + 4 months ($81.20); $3.99/month on 1 yearVPN Plus $2.99/month for the first 12 months ($35.88)
Price at renewalAutorenews at $81.20 every 3 years; 1-year plan renews at $47.88Renews at $83.88 every 12 months
Month to month$11.95$9.99 for VPN Plus
DevicesUnlimited10 on VPN Plus; 1 on Free
NetworkServers in 113 countries; RAM-only20,000+ servers in 140+ countries on VPN Plus
Base and ownerUnited States; Kape Technologies since 2019Switzerland; Proton AG, majority held by the non-profit Proton Foundation

Both pages show promotions: PIA labels its 3-year offer as early access to Black Friday, and Proton shows VPN Plus at 70% off. Offers change often, so confirm the renewal price in the order summary. Proton’s page also lists the Proton Unlimited bundle at $6.49 a month for the first year, renewing at $119.88 a year.

No-Logs Evidence: Three Audits Versus a Yearly Audit

PIA says it has had three third-party audits, all by Deloitte, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. CyberInsider reports that the latest, finished in December 2025 under the ISAE 3000 standard, also covered PIA’s token-based dedicated IP system. We have not read the reports. PIA also says its servers are RAM-only, so nothing is stored on a disk.

Proton VPN has used one firm, the Polish company Securitum, every year from 2022 to 2026. Its post, updated on 16 June 2026, calls the latest the fifth consecutive annual audit and quotes the 2026 report: the evidence “did not indicate” that the examined servers log browsing activity, DNS queries, destination services, traffic contents or user-identifiable connection metadata. The auditors also checked that the policy applies on free and paid plans and in every region. Proton publishes the full reports.

Yearly repetition with one method makes a quiet change to logging harder to hide. PIA’s record is shorter and less frequent, though it comes from a Big Four firm. Neither proves a no-logs claim forever, because an audit shows what was checked on a given date.

Court Cases and Transparency Reports

PIA’s claim has been tested in US federal court. In 2016 a criminal complaint in an FBI bomb-threat case said a subpoena to PIA’s then owner returned nothing useful about the suspect, according to TorrentFreak. In 2018 PIA’s general counsel testified in a San Jose federal court that PIA keeps no logs that could answer a subpoena, in a hacking case decided on other evidence, as TorrentFreak reported. PIA’s own page dates its two subpoenas to 2016 and 2017, so the years differ by source. Both came before Kape bought PIA in 2019.

PIA’s quarterly report for July to September 2026, updated on 5 November, lists two subpoenas, no warrants, four other government, law-enforcement or civil requests and three foreign or informal ones, with no logs produced for any.

Proton’s transparency report, updated on 14 July 2026, says it has received 458 legally binding orders approved by Swiss authorities since 2017, and shows 47 orders in the first half of 2026, 59 in 2025 and 53 in 2024, every one of the listed years marked as denied. Both reports are self-published, so they are the weakest layer next to the audits.

Price and Renewal: Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN

Proton’s first-year deal is cheaper than PIA’s 1-year plan, $35.88 against $47.88, but from the second year it costs $83.88 against $47.88. PIA’s 3-year offer is the lowest price on either page. Proton has one advantage no price comparison captures: you can run the free plan for as long as you like before paying.

Both give 30 days to ask for a refund on paid plans. PIA’s guarantee is for new subscribers only, and purchases made through an app store follow that store’s refund terms.

PlanFirst termRenewalDevices
PIA, 3 years + 4 months$2.03/mo ($81.20)$81.20 every 3 yearsUnlimited
PIA, 1 year$3.99/mo ($47.88)$47.88 a yearUnlimited
PIA, monthly$11.95$11.95Unlimited
Proton VPN Plus, 12 months$2.99/mo ($35.88)$83.88 every 12 months10
Proton VPN Plus, monthly$9.99Not stated10
Proton Free$0$01

Devices, Network and Free Plan

On devices, Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN is a split between unlimited and ten. PIA covers unlimited devices on one subscription and lists servers in 113 countries. Proton VPN Plus covers ten devices at a time and lists 20,000+ servers in more than 140 countries. Proton’s free plan is deliberately thin: one device, servers in ten countries picked for you, medium speed and no streaming, P2P or ad blocker. It is a good way to test the app, not a replacement for a paid plan.

Streaming and P2P are included on Proton VPN Plus. PIA’s page lists streaming and gaming among its uses, and our review notes port forwarding on every plan; if you need that feature, see our guide to a VPN with port forwarding. We have not measured speed for either. Your distance to the server decides more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.

Jurisdiction and Ownership

PIA is based in the United States, part of the Five Eyes group, and has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019. Our review notes that Kape also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost and began as Crossrider, a company known for bundling adware.

Proton is based in Geneva. Switzerland is outside the EU and the Five Eyes, and its current law does not require a VPN provider to keep connection logs. It is not a legal shield: in 2021 a Swiss court order led Proton Mail, the email service rather than the VPN, to record one activist’s IP address. In 2025 the Swiss government proposed rules that would require services with more than 5,000 users to store metadata such as IP addresses for six months, and Proton said it would leave Switzerland if they passed and began moving part of its infrastructure to Germany and Norway. As of 2026 the proposal is on hold pending a second consultation, so nothing has changed for users yet.

Ownership also differs. In 2024 Proton’s founders gave their shares to a new non-profit, the Proton Foundation, now the main shareholder, and no change of control can happen without its agreement.

Apps and Extras

Both describe their apps as open source. PIA has done so since 2018 and sells an antivirus add-on and a dedicated IP add-on at checkout, plus a free email breach monitor and 24/7 chat or email support. Our review adds that its interface has more settings than beginners need.

Proton VPN Plus adds Secure Core, which sends traffic through a first server in Switzerland, Iceland or Sweden before it exits in your chosen country, plus NetShield, which blocks ads, trackers and malware domains. Secure Core costs some speed; our guide to double VPN explains the trade-off. The Proton Unlimited bundle adds the Proton Pass password manager, encrypted email, calendar and storage.

Choose Private Internet Access if…

  • You have many devices or want unlimited connections.
  • You want the lowest long-term price and can commit to 3 years.
  • You want port forwarding in the standard plan.
  • You value a no-logs claim tested in US federal court.
  • You accept a US base and the Kape ownership history.

Choose Proton VPN if…

  • You want to try a free plan with no data cap first.
  • You want a larger server network and streaming support.
  • You like a yearly audit from the same firm.
  • You prefer a Swiss base and a non-profit as main shareholder.
  • You can live with the open question around Swiss surveillance law.

A Quick Way to Decide Between Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN

In a Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN decision, start with devices and budget: unlimited devices or the lowest three-year price points to PIA, and a free tier or a wider network points to Proton VPN. Then weigh the evidence you value more: a US court record and Deloitte audits, or a yearly audit and a non-profit owner. For other matches, see Proton VPN vs CyberGhost, NordVPN vs Private Internet Access and our best VPN rankings.

Verdict: Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN

Both back their privacy claims with evidence you can read. In this Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN comparison, PIA is the better pick for large households and anyone who wants the lowest long-term price, and Proton VPN is the better pick for readers who want a free plan, a bigger network and a yearly audit. The renewal prices matter as much as the first deal, so check them before you pay. The full detail is in our Private Internet Access review and Proton VPN review.

Private Internet Access vs Proton VPN: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Private Internet Access better than Proton VPN?

Neither wins on every point. PIA offers unlimited devices and the lowest long-term price, plus a no-logs claim tested in US federal court. Proton VPN offers a free plan, a larger network, ten devices and a yearly Securitum audit. Pick on the points that matter to you.

Which is cheaper, PIA or Proton VPN?

PIA on long plans: $2.03 a month on 3 years plus 4 months, against $2.99 for the first year of Proton VPN Plus, which then renews at $83.88 a year. Proton also has a free plan, and PIA does not. Both run promotions, so check the renewal price.

Does Proton VPN have a free plan and does PIA?

Proton VPN does: no data cap, one device, servers in 10 countries chosen for you. PIA has no free plan, only a 30-day money-back guarantee for new subscribers.

How many devices do PIA and Proton VPN allow?

PIA says one subscription covers unlimited devices at the same time. Proton VPN Plus covers ten devices, and the free plan covers one.

Have PIA and Proton VPN been audited?

Yes. PIA has had three Deloitte audits, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. Proton VPN has had a no-logs audit by Securitum every year from 2022 to 2026.

Who owns PIA and Proton VPN?

PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019. Proton AG is majority held by the non-profit Proton Foundation, created in 2024.

Sources