Skip to content

Private Internet Access vs Mullvad 2026: Which VPN Is Better?

Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.

This Private Internet Access vs Mullvad comparison sets two privacy-minded VPNs against each other that earn trust in different ways. Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, offers unlimited devices, open-source apps and a low price on long plans, and its no-logs claim has been tested in US federal court and checked by three Deloitte audits. Mullvad collects almost nothing at sign-up, charges one flat price and has a long list of audits by several firms, but it allows five devices and has no port forwarding.

Short version: pick PIA if you have many devices, want port forwarding or want the lowest long-term price. Pick Mullvad if you want a numbered account with no email, flat pricing and cash or crypto payment, and five devices is enough. In the Private Internet Access vs Mullvad match-up, neither rests on speed claims, because we have not measured any.

Private Internet Access vs Mullvad comparison card with both logos

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built

SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests for this page, so this Private Internet Access vs Mullvad page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our Private Internet Access review and our Mullvad review, plus pages we re-read in November 2026: PIA’s plans page and transparency report on 16 November, and Mullvad’s pricing and servers pages on 16 November. PIA’s prices are in dollars and Mullvad’s in euros, as each company lists them. Every source is linked at the end.

Private Internet Access vs Mullvad at a Glance

PIAMullvad
No-logs checks3 Deloitte audits: 2022, 2024, 2025Several firms, including Cure53, Assured, Leviathan Security and X41 D-Sec; latest in 2026
Real-world recordUS federal court cases in 2016 and 2018 produced no user data; quarterly transparency reports2023 police search in Gothenburg left with nothing (Mullvad’s account)
Sign-upNot covered in our sources; check at checkoutRandom account number, no email, username or password
Price$2.03/month for 3 years + 4 months ($81.20); $3.99/month on 1 year; $11.95 monthly€5 a month on every plan length (about $5.50 on its page)
DevicesUnlimited5
ServersServers in 113 countries; RAM-only570 servers in 50 countries and 91 cities; RAM-only
Port forwardingYes, per our reviewNo (removed in 2023)
Refund30 days, new subscribers only14 days, not for cash payments
Base and ownerUnited States; Kape Technologies since 2019Sweden; 100% owned by its founders

PIA’s page labels the 3-year offer as an early-access Black Friday deal, so prices may move. Mullvad’s price has not changed since 2009, according to its pricing page. We have not converted euros to dollars except where Mullvad’s own page shows it.

No-Logs Evidence: Three Audits Versus Several Firms

PIA says it has had three third-party audits. All three came from Deloitte: in 2022, 2024 and 2025. CyberInsider reports that the third, finished in December 2025 under the ISAE 3000 standard, also covered PIA’s token-based dedicated IP system and its incident handling. The reports are PIA’s to publish, and we have not read them ourselves. PIA also states that all of its servers run from RAM only, so nothing is written to a disk.

Mullvad lists audits by more than one firm. The newest in the sources we read are an Android app assessment by Leviathan Security Group (June 2026), a code review of GotaTun, its Rust version of WireGuard, by Assured Security Consultants (March 2026), a source-code audit of its account and payment services by X41 D-Sec (January 2026) and a fourth infrastructure audit by Cure53 in June 2024. That Cure53 audit covered one OpenVPN server, one WireGuard server on a staging environment and the Ansible code, not every production machine.

The two approaches differ. PIA has one large firm checking the same claim every second year or so, and Mullvad has many firms checking different pieces. A repeated audit by one method makes a quiet change harder to hide, while a mix covers more kinds of component. Neither proves a no-logs claim forever, because an audit shows what was checked on a given date.

Court Cases, Police Searches and Transparency Reports

Both have been tested outside a lab. In 2016 a criminal complaint in an FBI bomb-threat case said a subpoena to PIA’s then owner returned nothing useful about the suspect, according to TorrentFreak. In 2018 PIA’s general counsel testified in a San Jose federal court that PIA keeps no logs that could answer a subpoena, in a hacking case that ended in a conviction based on other evidence, as TorrentFreak reported. PIA’s own transparency page dates its two subpoenas to 2016 and 2017, so the years differ by source. Both cases came before Kape bought PIA in 2019, so they show how the company worked then.

On 18 April 2023, according to Mullvad’s own account, at least six police officers visited its Gothenburg office with a search warrant and left with nothing, because “such customer data did not exist”. That is Mullvad’s report, and the Swedish Prosecution Authority declined to give details.

PIA publishes a quarterly transparency report. The third-quarter 2026 edition, updated on 5 November, lists two subpoenas, no warrants, four other government, law-enforcement or civil requests and three foreign or informal ones, and says PIA produced no logs for any of them. Mullvad does not publish a report of the same kind in the sources we read. These reports are self-published, so they are the weakest layer of evidence.

Price and Payment: Private Internet Access vs Mullvad

PIA is far cheaper on a long plan. Mullvad’s page shows €5 as roughly $5.50, which would make 36 months about $198 against PIA’s $81.20 for the first 40 months. The trade is that Mullvad never changes: no deal to track, no renewal jump and no discount for committing. PIA’s offers carry a crossed-out price and a promotion label, so read the order summary before you pay.

Mullvad accepts cash, Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Monero, bank wire, credit card, PayPal and several European methods, and discounts the accepted cryptocurrencies by 10%. Mullvad says cash lets you “stay anonymous all the way”, and the 14-day guarantee does not cover cash payments because of anti-money-laundering rules. Card, PayPal and bank payments are handled by third parties and are not anonymous.

PlanPriceDevicesRefund
PIA, 3 years + 4 months$2.03/mo ($81.20 for the first term); the page says it autorenews at $81.20 every 3 yearsUnlimited30 days, new subscribers
PIA, 1 year$3.99/mo, billed $47.88 and then $47.88 a yearUnlimited30 days, new subscribers
PIA, monthly$11.95Unlimited30 days, new subscribers
Mullvad, any length€5/mo, flat, VAT included514 days, not for cash

Devices, Servers and Port Forwarding

On devices, Private Internet Access vs Mullvad is a clear split. PIA says one subscription covers unlimited simultaneous devices and lists servers in 113 countries, including all 50 US states. Mullvad allows up to five devices per account and lists 570 servers in 50 countries and 91 cities, run through 14 hosting providers. A large household or a shared account will hit Mullvad’s limit. If you want an uncommon country, PIA’s list is wider.

Our PIA review says it offers port forwarding on every plan, while Mullvad’s pricing page answers the same question with a plain “No”, and it removed the feature in 2023. If you need inbound ports for a torrent client or a home server, that settles it; see our guide to a VPN with port forwarding. We have not measured speed for either, and PIA’s “10-Gbps network” line is its own claim. Distance to the server and your own connection decide more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.

Ownership and Jurisdiction

Mullvad’s About page says Mullvad VPN AB and its parent company, Amagicom AB, are 100% owned by its two founders, which is unusually clear for a VPN company. It is based in Sweden and subject to Swedish law; our sources go no further than that, so we make no wider claim about Swedish surveillance rules.

PIA is based in the United States, which belongs to the Five Eyes group. It has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019, and our review notes that Kape also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost and began life as Crossrider, a company known for bundling adware. Ownership is not proof of bad behaviour, but it is a fair reason to read the audits and court record before you trust the no-logs claim.

Features Beyond the Basics

Mullvad’s About page gives a timeline: WireGuard from 2017, multihop on desktop from March 2022, a full move to RAM-only servers in September 2023, DAITA, its traffic-analysis defence, in May 2024, quantum-resistant tunnels by default in all apps from February 2025, and GotaTun in December 2025. DAITA needs Mullvad’s own app.

PIA describes its apps as 100% open source, a step it took in 2018, and sells an antivirus add-on and a dedicated IP add-on at checkout. It also includes an email breach monitor and 24/7 support by email or chat. Our review adds that its interface is busier than most and has more settings than beginners need.

Choose Private Internet Access if…

  • You have more than five devices or want unlimited connections.
  • You want port forwarding.
  • You want the lowest price on a long plan.
  • You value a no-logs claim tested in US federal court and checked by Deloitte.
  • You accept a US base and the Kape ownership history.

Choose Mullvad if…

  • You want the least possible data collected, with no email at sign-up.
  • You prefer one flat price with no deals or renewal jump.
  • You want to pay in cash or cryptocurrency.
  • Five devices is enough and you do not need port forwarding.
  • You want founder ownership and audits by several firms.

A Quick Way to Decide Between Private Internet Access vs Mullvad

In a Private Internet Access vs Mullvad decision, start with devices and ports: more than five devices or any need for port forwarding points to PIA. Then ask how much you want a provider to know about you. If the answer is as little as possible, Mullvad’s numbered account is hard to beat. If you are still undecided, compare the price over the term you would actually commit to. For other matches, see NordVPN vs Mullvad, NordVPN vs Private Internet Access and our best VPN rankings.

Verdict: Private Internet Access vs Mullvad

Both are privacy-focused services with evidence you can read, and neither needs an invented test. In this Private Internet Access vs Mullvad comparison, PIA is the better pick for large households, port forwarding and a low long-term price, and Mullvad is the better pick for readers who want minimal data collected, flat pricing and anonymous payment. Use the refund windows, 30 days at PIA and 14 days at Mullvad, to test your choice. The detail behind each point is in our Private Internet Access review and Mullvad review.

Private Internet Access vs Mullvad: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Private Internet Access better than Mullvad?

Neither wins on every point. PIA offers unlimited devices, port forwarding and a lower price on long plans. Mullvad collects almost nothing at sign-up, charges one flat price and has audits by several firms. Pick on the points that matter to you.

Which is cheaper, PIA or Mullvad?

PIA on long plans: $2.03 a month on 3 years plus 4 months on 16 November 2026, against a flat €5 (about $5.50) at Mullvad. PIA’s monthly plan is $11.95, so Mullvad is cheaper than PIA month to month.

How many devices do PIA and Mullvad allow?

PIA says one subscription covers unlimited devices at the same time. Mullvad allows up to five devices per account.

Does Mullvad or PIA have port forwarding?

PIA does, according to our review. Mullvad does not, and removed the feature in 2023.

Have PIA and Mullvad been audited?

Yes. PIA has had three Deloitte audits, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. Mullvad has been audited by several firms, including Cure53, Assured Security Consultants, Leviathan Security Group and X41 D-Sec.

Can I stay anonymous with Mullvad or PIA?

Mullvad is built for it: a random account number with no email, and cash or cryptocurrency payment. Our sources do not say what PIA collects at sign-up today, so check its checkout before you buy.

Sources