
McAfee
Best for unlimited devices
From$49.99first term*
McAfee+ Premium, unlimited devices
30-day money-back guarantee

Malwarebytes
Best for malware removal
From
60-day money-back guarantee
Prices are first-term prices read from each provider’s official U.S. page on November 14, 2026. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.
This McAfee vs Malwarebytes comparison sets a big-name suite sold on first-year discounts next to a lighter, cleanup-focused tool. Both score a perfect 18 out of 18 in AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round. AV-Comparatives separates them on false alarms: 4 for McAfee and 39 for Malwarebytes in its February to May 2026 test, even though McAfee protected against 98.5% of attacks and Malwarebytes 98.8%. Price, devices and bundled extras decide the rest.
Short version: pick McAfee if you want an unlimited-device plan or identity monitoring at a low first-year price. Pick Malwarebytes if you want a light program, strong adware cleanup and a free scanner, with a 60-day refund window. In the McAfee vs Malwarebytes match-up both stop nearly everything.

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built
SecureGuides has not run its own malware tests, so this McAfee vs Malwarebytes page relies on published labs and each company’s own pages. Lab figures come from AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 report and AV-Comparatives’ Real-World Protection Test for February to May 2026. We re-read McAfee’s Total Protection page and Malwarebytes’ pricing page on 15 November 2026, noting that Malwarebytes shows a device selector. Every source is linked at the end.
McAfee vs Malwarebytes at a Glance
| McAfee | Malwarebytes | |
|---|---|---|
| AV-TEST, Jul-Aug 2026 (protection / performance / usability) | 6 / 6 / 6 | 6 / 6 / 6 |
| AV-Comparatives, Feb-May 2026 | 98.5% protection, 4 false alarms | 98.8% protection, 39 false alarms, STANDARD |
| Entry price | $39.99 first year (5 devices, list $119.99) | $44.99/yr (1 device) or $59.99 (3 devices) |
| Unlimited-device plan | McAfee+ Premium, $49.99 first year (list $149.99) | None; Total covers 1 adult and 3 devices |
| Identity protection | Higher tiers, up to $2M theft coverage on Advanced | Total plan: $1M insurance |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days (60 days after a renewal, not monthly) | 60 days |
| Go to the provider | Visit McAfeemcafee.com | Visit Malwarebytesmalwarebytes.com |
Lab scores are from the reports cited above. Prices are as listed on each company’s own page on 15 November 2026, during Black Friday promotions, and change often. McAfee’s regular price is much higher than its first-year price.
Lab Results: Two Labs, One Close Race
In AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round of 15 home products on Windows 11, McAfee Total Protection 1.39 and Malwarebytes Premium 5.5 and 5.6 each scored 6 out of 6 for protection, performance and usability, 18 out of 18 in total. Most of the field did the same, so the round cannot pick a winner.
AV-Comparatives ran 400 attack scenarios between February and May 2026. Malwarebytes protected against 98.8% and McAfee against 98.5%, so the protection rates are nearly identical. The award is where they split: Malwarebytes fell to the entry-level STANDARD because of its 39 false alarms. Our Malwarebytes review explains why the two labs reached different verdicts.
False Alarms and What They Mean
AV-Comparatives counted 4 false alarms for McAfee and 39 for Malwarebytes, against a field average of 8. Malwarebytes takes a hard line on potentially unwanted programs, such as bundled toolbars and aggressive system cleaners, which is part of why people use it for cleanup and probably why it questions more borderline files.
McAfee’s clean round is not a guarantee: our McAfee product card notes an AV-Comparatives rating of TESTED, the lowest tier, in September 2025 because of 46 false alarms. Check the current round before you rely on one result.
Price and Renewal: McAfee vs Malwarebytes
| Plan | Price | Devices | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| McAfee Total Protection | $39.99 first year (list $119.99) | 5 | Renews at the regular price unless cancelled |
| McAfee+ Premium | $49.99 first year (list $149.99) | Unlimited | Identity monitoring |
| McAfee+ Advanced | $89.99 first year (list $199.99) | Unlimited | Adds identity restoration, up to $2M theft coverage |
| Malwarebytes Standard | $44.99/yr (1 device) or $59.99/yr (3 devices) | 1 or 3 | Antivirus, scam and ad blocker |
| Malwarebytes Plus | $79.98/yr | 3 | Adds a VPN |
| Malwarebytes Total | $89.99/yr, marked down from $179.99 | 1 adult and 3 devices | Adds identity protection, $1M insurance |
McAfee is cheaper per device in the first year and its unlimited-device tiers have no Malwarebytes equivalent. The catch is the gap between the first-year price and the list price: McAfee lists $119.99 for Total Protection against $39.99 for the first year, and its terms say the subscription renews automatically, charged 30 days before the term ends. Cancel at least 31 days earlier if you do not want it.
Malwarebytes is cheaper for a single device and gives 60 days to ask for a refund, against McAfee’s 30. It shows the three-device price on its main cards and the one-device price in a separate “fewer devices” offer, and it marks its Total plan down by half, which is a promotion rather than a regular price. Compare the same device count before you decide.
Features in McAfee vs Malwarebytes
McAfee’s higher plans lean on identity: 24/7 monitoring and alerts, and on Advanced personal-information removal and identity restoration with up to $2M of theft coverage, as its page describes. Its unlimited plans cover household devices you own for personal use and are subject to a fair-use policy.
Malwarebytes does fewer things on purpose. It has no firewall of its own, no parental controls and no password manager. What it has is a small footprint, a strong record at removing adware and unwanted programs, a scam and ad blocker, a VPN on the Plus plan and a free Browser Guard extension. The free download is only a manual scanner.
Windows users should also weigh Microsoft Defender, which scored 99.0% with no false alarms in the same AV-Comparatives test; see our guide to Windows Defender vs third-party antivirus. For related comparisons, see Bitdefender vs McAfee and Norton vs Malwarebytes.
Privacy and Data Practices
Both rely on cloud data for detection, and McAfee’s identity tiers also handle personal details such as email addresses. Neither publishes a no-logs audit of the kind VPN companies do, so read each privacy policy for what it collects.
Choose McAfee if…
- You want an unlimited-device plan for a big household.
- You want identity monitoring and theft coverage in the same subscription.
- You want the lowest first-year price per device.
- You will track the renewal date, because the regular price is much higher.
Choose Malwarebytes if…
- You want a light program and strong cleanup of adware and unwanted software.
- You like a free scanner and a free browser extension alongside the paid version.
- You want a 60-day refund window to test it.
- You can live without a firewall, parental controls and a password manager.
A Quick Way to Decide Between McAfee vs Malwarebytes
Start with devices and identity: unlimited devices or identity monitoring point to McAfee. A light cleanup tool and a free scanner point to Malwarebytes. If neither decides it, the false-alarm record favours McAfee, 4 against 39, and the refund window favours Malwarebytes. For the wider field, see our TotalAV vs McAfee comparison.
Verdict: McAfee vs Malwarebytes
Both are well-tested. In this McAfee vs Malwarebytes comparison, McAfee is the better pick for a large household or anyone who wants identity monitoring at a low first-year price, and Malwarebytes is the better pick for someone who wants a light, focused tool, strong cleanup and a long refund window. Read our Malwarebytes review for more on Malwarebytes, and use the refund windows to test whichever you choose.
McAfee vs Malwarebytes: Frequently Asked Questions
Is McAfee better than Malwarebytes?
Not on every point. Both scored 18 out of 18 in AV-TEST’s July and August 2026 round. McAfee had 4 false alarms in AV-Comparatives’ February to May 2026 test against 39 for Malwarebytes, but Malwarebytes protected against slightly more attacks, 98.8% against 98.5%.
Which is cheaper, McAfee or Malwarebytes?
McAfee in the first year: $39.99 for five devices on 15 November 2026, against $59.99 for three devices on Malwarebytes Standard. For one device Malwarebytes was $44.99. McAfee lists much higher regular prices, so check the renewal rate.
Which covers more devices?
McAfee, through its unlimited-device plans. Malwarebytes Standard covers one or three devices.
Does Malwarebytes replace Microsoft Defender?
The paid Premium plan becomes your main antivirus. The free version is only an on-demand scanner, so Defender keeps running next to it.
Which has the longer money-back guarantee?
Malwarebytes, at 60 days. McAfee gives 30 days, plus 60 days after a renewal charge on annual plans.
Do I need either on Windows 11?
Not necessarily. Microsoft Defender scored 99.0% with no false alarms in the same AV-Comparatives test.


