Skip to content

Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN 2026: Which VPN Is Better?

Prices change with promotions, so we do not repeat them here. See each provider’s page for the current price. Buttons open the provider’s own site and may earn us a commission, which does not change our verdict.

This Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN comparison looks at two VPNs that sit under the same owner and still differ a lot. Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, offers unlimited devices, open-source apps and one of the lowest prices on long plans. ExpressVPN has a longer audit list, a server design that survived a real police seizure and a price that rises sharply at renewal. Both belong to Kape, so the choice comes down to evidence, devices and cost over time.

Short version: pick PIA if you have many devices, want port forwarding or care about the long-term price. Pick ExpressVPN if you want the longest audit list, router support and the strongest independent real-world proof, and you will track the renewal. In the Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN match-up we have not measured speed for either.

Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN comparison card with both logos

A Note on How This Comparison Was Built

SecureGuides has not run its own speed or streaming tests for this page, so this Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN page does not name a speed winner. The facts come from the sources behind our Private Internet Access review and our ExpressVPN review, plus pages we re-read in November 2026: PIA’s plans page and transparency report on 16 November, and ExpressVPN’s pricing page on 17 November and Trust Center on 17 November. ExpressVPN lowered its listed prices between our 15 and 17 November readings, so treat every price here as a snapshot. Every source is linked at the end.

Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN at a Glance

FeaturePIAExpressVPN
No-logs checks3 Deloitte audits: 2022, 2024, 2025PwC (2019); KPMG audits of its privacy commitments (2022, 2023, 2025)
Real-world recordUS federal court cases in 2016 and 2018 produced no user data2017 Turkey server seizure found no user data
Transparency reportQuarterly; Q3 2026 lists 9 requests, no logs producedTwice a year; January to June 2026 lists 137 requests and 3 warrants
Price, first term$2.03/month for 3 years + 4 months ($81.20)Basic $2.79/month for 2 years + 4 months ($78.12)
Price at renewalAutorenews at $81.20 every 3 yearsBasic renews at $99.95 a year
DevicesUnlimited10 / 12 / 14 by tier
ServersServers in 113 countries; RAM-onlyServers in 113 countries; TrustedServer RAM-only design
Port forwardingYes, per our reviewNo, per our review
Refund30 days, new subscribers only30 days, new users
Base and ownerUnited States; Kape Technologies since 2019British Virgin Islands; Kape Technologies since 2021

Both pages show Black Friday promotions, so prices may move again. PIA’s figures are from 16 November and ExpressVPN’s from 17 November. Both are in dollars, as each company lists them.

No-Logs Evidence: Three Audits Versus a Long List

PIA says it has had three third-party audits, all by Deloitte, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. CyberInsider reports that the latest, finished in December 2025 under the ISAE 3000 standard, also covered PIA’s token-based dedicated IP system. We have not read the reports. PIA says its servers run from RAM only, so nothing is written to a disk.

ExpressVPN’s Trust Center lists a long run of external audits. Most examine code and apps: Cure53 has reviewed its apps, its Lightway protocol, its Aircove routers and newer products such as ExpressKeys. The ones that speak to logging are PwC Switzerland’s 2019 review of its privacy policy and TrustedServer technology, and three KPMG audits of its privacy commitments, in September 2022, December 2023 and June 2025. TrustedServer is a RAM-only design that rebuilds each server on reboot.

So ExpressVPN has more audits and two Big Four firms, while PIA has a steady run from one. Neither proves a no-logs claim forever, because an audit shows what was checked on a given date.

Court Cases, Seizures and Transparency Reports

Both have been tested outside an audit. In 2016 a criminal complaint in an FBI bomb-threat case said a subpoena to PIA’s then owner returned nothing useful about the suspect, according to TorrentFreak. In 2018 PIA’s general counsel testified in a San Jose federal court that PIA keeps no logs that could answer a subpoena, in a hacking case decided on other evidence, as TorrentFreak reported. PIA’s own page dates its two subpoenas to 2016 and 2017, so the years differ by source. Both came before Kape bought PIA in 2019.

In 2017 Turkish authorities seized an ExpressVPN server during the investigation of the assassination of Russia’s ambassador and found nothing that identified a user, as TorrentFreak reported. Because the seizure was not arranged by the company, it is the stronger independent proof of the two, though it is a single event.

PIA’s quarterly report for July to September 2026 lists two subpoenas, no warrants, four other government, law-enforcement or civil requests and three foreign or informal ones, with no logs produced. ExpressVPN’s report for January to June 2026 lists 137 government, law-enforcement and civil requests and three warrants, and says it never has user data to share. Both reports are self-published.

Price and Renewal: Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN

The first terms are close: $81.20 for 40 months at PIA against $78.12 for 28 months at ExpressVPN Basic. The gap opens at renewal. Three years of ExpressVPN Basic at its renewal price come to $299.85, against $81.20 for a PIA three-year renewal. ExpressVPN’s page does not list a month-to-month price in the text we read, so check the order summary.

Both give 30 days to ask for a refund, and both limit it to new customers. For PIA, purchases through an app store follow that store’s own refund terms.

PlanFirst termRenewalDevices
PIA, 3 years + 4 months$2.03/mo ($81.20)$81.20 every 3 yearsUnlimited
PIA, 1 year$3.99/mo ($47.88)$47.88 a yearUnlimited
PIA, monthly$11.95$11.95Unlimited
ExpressVPN Basic$2.79/mo ($78.12 for 28 months)$99.95 a year10
ExpressVPN Advanced$3.99/mo ($111.72 for 28 months)$119.95 a year12
ExpressVPN Express Pro$6.99/mo ($195.72 for 28 months)$199.95 a year14

Devices, Servers and Port Forwarding

On devices, Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN is a split between unlimited and ten to fourteen. PIA says one subscription covers unlimited simultaneous devices, while ExpressVPN covers 10 on Basic, 12 on Advanced and 14 on Express Pro. Both list servers in 113 countries on their pricing pages.

Our PIA review says it offers port forwarding on every plan, while our ExpressVPN review notes that ExpressVPN removed it. If you need inbound ports, see our guide to a VPN with port forwarding. We have not measured speed for either. PIA calls its network 10-Gbps and ExpressVPN lists speeds up to 40Gbps, but those are company claims. Your distance to the server decides more than the brand, as our explainer on whether a VPN slows down your internet shows.

Same Owner, Different Bases

PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019 and ExpressVPN since 2021, according to our reviews, which also note that Kape owns CyberGhost and began life as Crossrider, a company known for bundling adware. Choosing between these two does not move you away from Kape. It only changes which of its brands you pay.

The legal base differs. PIA is in the United States, part of the Five Eyes group. ExpressVPN is in the British Virgin Islands, outside the Five Eyes and without mandatory data-retention laws. Our ExpressVPN review also covers a 2021 disclosure about a senior executive.

Features Beyond the Basics

PIA describes its apps as 100% open source, a step it took in 2018, and sells an antivirus add-on and a dedicated IP add-on at checkout, plus a free email breach monitor and 24/7 chat or email support. Our review adds that its interface has more settings than beginners need.

ExpressVPN offers its own Lightway protocol, split tunneling on several platforms, Aircove routers with setup guides and a dedicated IP that is an add-on on Basic and Advanced and included in Express Pro. Its higher tiers now bundle ExpressKeys, ExpressMailGuard and ExpressAI, which are separate products with their own limits.

Choose Private Internet Access if…

  • You have many devices or want unlimited connections.
  • You want port forwarding and open-source apps.
  • You care about the price after the first term.
  • You value a no-logs claim tested in US federal court.

Choose ExpressVPN if…

  • You want the longest audit list, with PwC and KPMG on logging.
  • You want router support and a simple, polished app.
  • You value a seizure that found nothing, not arranged by the company.
  • You will track the renewal date, because the price jumps.

A Quick Way to Decide Between Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN

In a Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN decision, start with devices and ports: more than fourteen devices or any need for port forwarding points to PIA. Then weigh the evidence you value more: a longer audit list and a seizure (ExpressVPN) or a US court record and a lower renewal (PIA). For other matches, see ExpressVPN vs Mullvad, NordVPN vs Private Internet Access and our best VPN rankings.

Verdict: Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN

Both are audited services with documented records, owned by the same company. In this Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN comparison, PIA is the better pick for large households and anyone who cares about the long-term price, and ExpressVPN is the better pick for readers who want the longest audit list, router support and a polished app, as long as they plan for the renewal. Use the 30-day refund windows to test your choice. The detail behind each point is in our Private Internet Access review and ExpressVPN review.

Private Internet Access vs ExpressVPN: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Private Internet Access better than ExpressVPN?

Neither wins on every point. PIA offers unlimited devices, port forwarding and a lower renewal price. ExpressVPN offers a longer audit list, router support and a seizure that found no user data. Pick on the points that matter to you.

Which is cheaper, PIA or ExpressVPN?

The first terms are close: $2.03 a month for PIA on 3 years plus 4 months, and $2.79 for ExpressVPN Basic on 2 years plus 4 months. At renewal PIA asks $81.20 every three years, while ExpressVPN Basic asks $99.95 a year.

How many devices do PIA and ExpressVPN allow?

PIA says one subscription covers unlimited devices at the same time. ExpressVPN covers 10 on Basic, 12 on Advanced and 14 on Express Pro.

Have PIA and ExpressVPN been audited?

Yes. PIA has had three Deloitte audits, in 2022, 2024 and 2025. ExpressVPN lists a PwC review in 2019 and KPMG audits in 2022, 2023 and 2025, plus many security audits of its apps and products.

Do PIA and ExpressVPN have the same owner?

Yes. PIA has belonged to Kape Technologies since 2019 and ExpressVPN since 2021, according to our reviews.

Does PIA or ExpressVPN have port forwarding?

PIA does, according to our review. ExpressVPN removed it, according to our review.

Sources